438 North Tioga Street

Handsome downtown two family home just 3.5 blocks to the Ithaca Commons and a stones throw to scenic Cascadilla Creek. 3 bedrooms and 1 bath upstairs and a large 2 bedroom, 1 bath on the main floor. Split gas and electric meters. Classic Italianate style entry plus a covered wrap around front porch for watching the days go by or enjoying the hustle and bustle of Fall Creek. Many updates and improvements. New roof, gutters, newer furnaces, updated windows and siding and much more. Spacious living rooms and kitchens. HUGE fenced in downtown yard ideal for gatherings, gardens, pets and more. Wonderful location so close to restaurants, festivals, shops and more. Bike lane and bus stop right out front. Could possibly be converted back to a single family. Very well maintained and cared for by current owner for 35 years. Great for owner occupied with solid rental income or use as an investment property.


  • 5 bedrooms total
  • 2 full baths
  • 3 bedroom apartment up
  • 2 bedroom apartment down
  • Separate utilities
  • Ceramic tiled floors
  • Spacious units
  • Updated windows
  • New roof
  • Updated mechanics
  • Huge lot
  • Fenced in
  • Wrap around front porch
  • Could be a large single family
  • 2.5 blocks to Ithaca Commons
  • On bus route and bike lane

Property Details:

  • Address: 438 North Tioga Street, Ithaca, New York 14850 
  • Price: $349,900 
  • MLS #: 402705 
  • Location: Fall Creek 
  • Bedrooms:
  • Bathrooms:
  • Lot Size: 44 x 132 
  • School District: Ithaca City Schools